For some fans, a special edition DVD isn’t enough—they want more. Scream has always carried a sense of nostalgia, with its clever nods to horror classics making it an irresistible watch. But for superfans, the connection goes far deeper. In light of the Scream 4 props auction, we sat down with “William” from BillyLoomis.com to talk about his impressive collection.

How did Scream become part of your life? What drew you to the movie?

I remember not knowing much about Scream before I saw it. I had only seen the trailer, but a friend recommended it, saying it was amazing. So, I rented it from my local video store before heading to her house. I planned to return it that same night—but the movie left such an impression that I didn’t return it for three days. I must have watched it six times in that span! Eventually, I rented it again and made a VHS-to-VHS copy (this was pre-DVD days), and I watched that tape to the point of exhaustion until the official release.

Where and how did you start your collection?

The following summer, Scream: The Director’s Cut was released on VHS. I rented it right away and knew I had to own it. It wasn’t for sale yet, but I was close friends with my local video store owner, and he sold me one of his copies. Not long after, my best friend called to say a downtown store had a limited-edition Scream Director’s Cut box set for sale. Only 1,500 copies were made. The set included the VHS Director’s Cut, a Ghostface mask, and a signed certificate with its production number. I went to the store immediately and bought it. Seeing the Ghostface mask staring back at me in the box solidified my love for the movie. From there, I started collecting everything from magazine clippings to screen-used props.

What is your favorite item in your Scream collection? Which one is the most valuable?

Matthew Lillard’s screen-worn outfit from Scream’s third act. The ensemble includes the bloody pants, the sweater with knife cuts, and even a candy wrapper in the back pocket! It’s my most cherished piece and undoubtedly the most valuable.

Where do you keep and how do you maintain your collection? Do you display it publicly?

Unfortunately, I don’t have the space to display everything as I’d like. Plus, my cats would have a field day climbing up my screen-worn wardrobe! I’m considering turning the master bedroom into a Scream memorabilia room. Thankfully, my wife is very understanding—haha!

Is Scream the only movie you collect memorabilia from, or do you have other interests?

Scream is the only movie I’ve ever felt so passionate about. Everything about it—the atmosphere, the cast, the story, the direction—it’s perfect to me. I feel similarly about Scream 2, although Scream 3 doesn’t quite measure up to the first two.

Do you have any advice for new collectors?

No item is too small! I started with modest finds. Living in a small European country, I relied on the internet to connect with people worldwide and expand my search for memorabilia. It took 13 years to build my collection to where it is today, and I’m still excited to keep collecting. Every Halloween, I check for new Scream-related items. Even a $2 plastic knife with a Scream tag brings me the same joy I felt 13 years ago when I saw Ghostface staring back at me in that video store.

Thank you, William, for sharing your story. Keep on Screaming!